The 10 Most Scenic Caribbean Islands: A Supremarine Curated Escape

Some places stay with you—not just in photos, but in memory. The Caribbean is full of them. With its mix of bold landscapes, quiet beaches, and open water, it's a region where natural beauty meets timeless calm. But among the many islands, a few stand out—not just for how they look, but for how they make you feel.

At Supremarine, we’ve chosen 10 destinations that capture this balance. These are the most scenic Caribbean islands—places where the views are stunning, the experiences are rich, and the connection to the ocean runs deep. Whether you’re drawn to dramatic coastlines or peaceful bays, these islands offer something rare: beauty that doesn’t try too hard.

‎

At a Glance: The Most Scenic Islands in the Caribbean

1. St. Barts
2. St. Lucia
3. Turks and Caicos
4. Antigua
5. Virgin Gorda
6. Curaçao
7. Anguilla
8. Bonaire
9. Nevis
10. Harbour Island (Bahamas)

‎

Why These 10?

Out of hundreds of destinations across the region, these 10 islands stand apart for their visual character and sense of place. They each offer something distinct—sharp mountain peaks, pink-sand beaches, coral reefs, or coastlines that stretch into quiet, endless blue. But what connects them all is how naturally they embody what travelers look for when they search for the most scenic Caribbean islands.

We didn’t choose based on popularity—we chose based on presence. These are places where the landscape feels immersive, where the sea is always part of the experience, and where the scenery is matched by a sense of refinement and calm. For travelers who want more than just pretty views, these are the islands that deliver.

‎‎

1. St. Barts

We didn’t include St. Barts because it’s famous—we included it because it delivers. For an island this small, it offers a rare level of visual precision: bold, clean coastlines, sea views that feel designed, and an architecture that never competes with the setting. It’s one of the most scenic Caribbean islands not because it tries, but because it doesn’t have to.

The scenery doesn’t overwhelm; it settles in. White villas sit lightly on the hills, red roofs give Gustavia a quiet rhythm, and beaches like Colombier and Gouverneur feel protected—not just from crowds, but from noise. St. Barts is luxury without excess.

For us, that balance—between nature, taste, and restraint—is what earns it a place on this list.

‎‎

2. St. Lucia

Some islands are soft and easy—St. Lucia makes you look up. It’s a place where the landscape takes the lead. The twin Pitons rising straight from the sea are more than just a view—they set the tone for the entire island: bold, grounded, and unforgettable.

What puts St. Lucia among the most scenic islands in the Caribbean isn’t just those iconic peaks—it’s the way sea, jungle, and volcanic rock all collide in a way that still feels untouched. You don’t just lounge here; you move through it—on the water, through the rainforest, along trails with actual elevation. And when you stop? You’re rewarded with some of the most panoramic views in the Caribbean.

St. Lucia isn’t curated beauty. It’s raw form, shaped by time, and left mostly alone. That’s what makes it stand out—and why it belongs here.

‎

3. Turks and Caicos

Some islands invite you in with color. Turks and Caicos wins you over with space. It’s the clarity—the open sky, the endless horizon, the water so still and glass-like it almost disappears. You don’t just see the island, you breathe it in.

What makes it one of the most beautiful islands in the Caribbean is its simplicity. Grace Bay stretches long and wide, untouched by cliffs or crowding. The sand is pale and fine, the kind that never burns your feet. Offshore, coral reefs frame the view below, while sailing through the shallows gives you a front-row seat to one of the calmest, most luminous seascapes in the region.

Turks and Caicos doesn’t need drama. Its power is in its calm. That, too, is a kind of beauty.

‎

4. Antigua

Antigua doesn’t need a dramatic skyline or towering peaks—it just keeps showing up, one perfect coastline at a time. With 365 beaches, each shaped by the tide in its own way, this is an island that understands consistency. It’s not loud, but it’s endlessly layered.

What places Antigua among the most scenic islands in the Caribbean is the way land and sea work together here. The harbors curve gently, the hills rise just enough to give you a view, and the water—always close—follows you wherever you go. English Harbour is both a historic landmark and a lookout. Even from Shirley Heights, the island holds its shape in quiet confidence.

Antigua doesn’t chase attention. It earns it—beach by beach, bay by bay.

‎

5. Virgin Gorda

Virgin Gorda feels like it was never meant to be found—like the sea kept it for itself. The island’s coastline is a study in contrast: smooth water meets giant granite boulders, tide pools form between them, and sunbeams cut cleanly through every crevice. It’s not dramatic, it’s elemental.

The Baths may be its most photographed spot, but they’re just one part of the whole. Sail along the southern edge and you’ll find hidden beaches, sharp rock formations, and water so still it reflects everything. Virgin Gorda earns its place among the most beautiful islands in the Caribbean by staying grounded—letting the landscape do the work.

No staging. No excess. Just place, exactly as it is.

‎

6. Curaçao

Curaçao doesn’t need to shout to stand out. It’s color, quietly done right—where pastel streets lead to hidden coves and reefs stretch out just beyond the shore. The island has shape and texture, not just from its coastline, but from how every element sits naturally in place.

Willemstad draws you in first, with Dutch facades mirrored in still harbor waters. Then the west side takes over: limestone cliffs, tucked-away beaches, and water that turns a deeper shade of blue the longer you stay. It’s one of the most scenic Caribbean islands because it’s not just a beach destination—it’s a place built on layers.

Curaçao doesn’t demand attention. It earns it, frame by frame.

‎

7. Anguilla

Anguilla doesn’t overpromise. It doesn’t need to. What it offers is purity—long stretches of white sand, water so pale it seems brushed on, and a rhythm that moves slower than most. The island is almost impossibly flat, but that’s what makes its beaches feel endless.

There are no dramatic peaks here, no towering cliffs—just the open horizon and a coastline that never interrupts itself. Shoal Bay alone could earn it a place among the most scenic islands in the Caribbean, but the appeal runs deeper: quiet coves, soft light, and a stillness that feels rare.

It’s the kind of island that makes you notice what you usually miss.

‎

8. Bonaire

Bonaire doesn’t make a big first impression. It waits. But once you're in the water, it opens up completely. Coral walls, sea turtles, and reef systems just offshore make the island feel more alive below the surface than above. And that’s exactly the point.

Unlike its flashier neighbors, Bonaire stays grounded. The coast is rugged, the cacti stand tall, and the rhythm of life moves with the tide. For divers and nature-focused travelers, it’s one of the most beautiful islands in the Caribbean—not for what it shows at a glance, but for what it reveals over time.

Some islands are loud. Bonaire is lasting.

‎

9. Nevis

Nevis is all slope and stillness. The island rises gently from the sea, with Mount Nevis at the center like a quiet anchor. From nearly anywhere, you’re looking at some part of the island framed by sea, palms, and sky. It feels composed without being touched.

There’s no rush here. Historic inns sit tucked into old plantations, and beaches stretch on with barely a footprint. The views are wide, the hills soft, and the sea always nearby. Nevis earns its place among the most scenic Caribbean islands because nothing about it is overstated.

It simply gets everything right, without ever trying too hard.

‎

10. Harbour Island (Bahamas)

Some places are defined by a single color. Harbour Island’s is pink. Its beach stretches wide and soft, tinted by crushed coral and lit by clear Bahamian light. But it’s not just the sand—it’s the quiet rhythm of golf carts on narrow streets, the pastel cottages, and the stillness between tides.

This isn’t a showy island. It’s one you settle into. Walk far enough down the beach and it feels like the edge of something—just sand, sea, and space. Among the most scenic islands in the Caribbean, Harbour Island earns its place through subtlety, not spectacle.

It leaves an impression by never asking for one.

‎

Takeaway

The Caribbean isn’t short on beautiful places—but not all beauty lingers. These ten islands rise above not just for their views, but for the way they hold them. They don’t compete for attention. They don’t follow a script. They simply reflect what makes this region unforgettable: land shaped by water, and time slowed by the sea.

If you’re searching for the most scenic Caribbean islands, don’t just look for what stands out. Look for what stays with you.