The Top Resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025: Year-End Wrap-Up

As the year winds down, it’s the perfect moment to revisit the stays that truly captured the spirit of island travel — the experiences, the design moments, and the resorts that kept travelers talking. Our year-end wrap-up of the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025 brings together the properties that stood out not just for their beaches, but for how they shaped the way we escape, unwind, and reconnect in the Caribbean.

From private-island hideaways to cliffside architectural marvels, this recap looks at what made each place special and why they earned a place among the Top Resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025. Think of it as a curated snapshot of the year’s best — a guide to where Caribbean travel truly excelled.

‎

Why These Resorts

To create this year-end wrap-up, we focused on the resorts that shaped the Caribbean’s luxury landscape in 2025. Our criteria centered on places that delivered more than a great view — properties that offered a strong sense of place, consistently positive guest experiences, and a clear identity within their island.

We evaluated each resort through five key lenses:

• Location & Natural Setting – Beach quality, privacy, and how well the resort connects guests to its island.
• Design & Distinctive Character – Architectural impact, atmosphere, craftsmanship, and uniqueness.
• Service & Amenities – Dining, wellness programs, attention to detail, and the overall guest journey.
• Guest Satisfaction Themes – What travelers repeatedly appreciated across major platforms (no ratings fabricated).
• 2025 Relevance – Renovations, awards momentum, wellness initiatives, or standout moments from the year.

This mix allowed us to highlight resorts that didn’t just perform well — they defined the Caribbean experience in 2025.

‎

#10 – Four Seasons Resort Nevis (Nevis)

Kicking off the list at #10, Four Seasons Resort Nevis brings an easygoing, polished take on Caribbean luxury along the golden curve of Pinney’s Beach. Its relaxed elegance and spacious grounds made it a steady favorite for travelers looking to wind down somewhere calm and unhurried.

Why It’s in Contention

This resort earned its place for dependable service, a versatile beach layout, and a genuine island warmth that resonated with guests all year. It also remained a steady performer among the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, thanks to its approachable luxury and consistently positive reviews from couples and families alike.

Best For

Guests who appreciate understated luxury with plenty of breathing room — especially those who prefer a calm, refined beachfront setting rather than a high-energy resort scene.

Fun Fact

Nevis is home to thousands of green vervet monkeys, and sightings around the resort’s gardens and pathways are part of its everyday island personality.

‎

#9 – Silversands Grenada (Grenada)

Easing into the #9 spot, Silversands Grenada brings a strikingly modern aesthetic to the iconic sweep of Grand Anse Beach. Its clean lines, long infinity pool, and understated luxury made it one of the most visually distinctive places travelers gravitated toward as the year wound down.

Why It’s in Contention

Silversands earned its ranking for delivering a contemporary, design-forward take on Caribbean beachfront living. Its calm, minimalist atmosphere and strong sense of place helped solidify its position among the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, especially for travelers seeking something fresher and more architectural than the typical tropical resort.

Best For

Design-conscious guests who appreciate modern minimalism, quiet luxury, and a beachfront setting that feels refined without being overly formal.

Fun Fact

The resort’s 100-meter pool is one of the longest in the Caribbean, creating a dramatic focal point that runs almost directly into the horizon.

‎

#8 – The Ocean Club, A Four Seasons Resort (Bahamas)

Arriving at #8, The Ocean Club brings a sense of understated glamour to the white sands of Paradise Island. With manicured gardens, elegant low-rise architecture, and a long tradition of catering to privacy-minded guests, it remained a favorite for travelers seeking a polished year-end escape.

Why It’s in Contention

The resort stands out for its blend of heritage charm and contemporary Four Seasons refinement. Its generous beachfront, meticulous landscaping, and consistently praised service helped secure its place among the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, especially for guests who value sophistication over flash.

Best For

Travelers who appreciate classic luxury with a quiet, cultivated atmosphere — ideal for those who want beach relaxation paired with a refined, grown-up setting.

Fun Fact

Its Versailles-inspired gardens were originally designed as a private passion project in the 1960s and remain one of the Bahamas’ most iconic landscaped spaces.

‎

#7 – Jumby Bay Island (Antigua)

Landing at #7, Jumby Bay Island offers an elevated take on the private-island experience just off the coast of Antigua. Accessible only by boat and defined by its low-key elegance, open spaces, and breezy island atmosphere, it offered one of the most effortless year-end luxury escapes in the region.

Why It’s in Contention

Jumby Bay earns its place for delivering a rare mix of seclusion, attentive service, and all-inclusive ease at an ultra-luxury level. Its blend of privacy, generous island-wide amenities, and consistently warm guest feedback kept it firmly in the conversation for the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, especially among travelers who value simplicity without sacrificing comfort.

Best For

Guests who want a private-island feel with all-inclusive convenience — ideal for those who prefer wide-open spaces, quiet beaches, and a don’t-lift-a-finger style of luxury.

Fun Fact

The island is a protected sanctuary for endangered Hawksbill turtles, and during nesting season, guests can often witness hatchlings making their way to the sea.

‎

#6 – COMO Parrot Cay (Turks & Caicos)

Moving into the #6 spot, COMO Parrot Cay remains one of the region’s most beloved private-island retreats, defined by soft-white beaches, wellness-led experiences, and a minimalist design language that encourages guests to slow down. Its calm, restorative energy made it a standout choice for travelers closing out their year in a more mindful way.

Why It’s in Contention

The resort secured its place for its holistic approach to luxury — thoughtful wellness programming, understated villas, and the signature serenity that COMO is known for. These qualities helped it remain a strong contender among the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, especially for guests who wanted privacy and purposeful relaxation rather than high spectacle.

Best For

Wellness-focused travelers, privacy seekers, and guests who appreciate a soothing, pared-back environment where spa rituals and calm beaches take center stage.

Fun Fact

The resort’s COMO Shambhala Retreat is internationally recognized and attracts wellness practitioners from around the world for seasonal residencies.

‎

#5 – Amanera (Dominican Republic)

Entering the top five, Amanera brings a striking blend of cliffside drama and minimalist design to the north coast of the Dominican Republic. Overlooking Playa Grande’s untamed shoreline, the resort’s clean architecture and deep sense of calm made it a memorable choice for travelers seeking a more meditative year-end escape.

Why It’s in Contention

Amanera earned its position through its architectural significance, Aman-caliber service, and immersive natural setting. Its thoughtful integration with the landscape kept it highly regarded among the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, appealing to guests who value impeccable detail, quiet spaces, and a sanctuary-like atmosphere.

Best For

Design-minded travelers, wellness seekers, and guests who appreciate refined, minimalist spaces framed by wild, cinematic coastlines.

Fun Fact

The resort sits beside Playa Grande Golf Course, one of the last courses designed by legendary architect Robert Trent Jones Sr., with several cliffside holes offering sweeping ocean views.

‎

#4 – Eden Rock St Barths (St. Barts)

Settling into the #4 spot, Eden Rock St Barths continues to embody the effortless glamour that defines the island. Perched on a rocky promontory over the turquoise waters of St. Jean Bay, the resort blends boutique intimacy with a lively, fashion-forward energy that drew end-of-year travelers looking for something stylish yet iconic.

Why It’s in Contention

Eden Rock holds its rank for its unmistakable identity — a mix of refined service, bold personality, and a beachfront location that remains one of the most photographed in the Caribbean. It consistently held its place among the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, especially for travelers seeking a blend of high-end hospitality and jet-set ambiance.

Best For

Style-driven guests, culinary travelers, and anyone who appreciates boutique luxury with a glamorous, social edge.

Fun Fact

The property was once the private home of aviator Rémy de Haenen, who helped pioneer the island’s early aviation history — the runway at St. Barts still aligns with views of the resort.

‎

#3 – Cap Juluca, A Belmond Hotel (Anguilla)

Gliding into the #3 position, Cap Juluca brings a serene, luminous beauty to Anguilla’s famed Maundays Bay. Its whitewashed, Moorish-inspired architecture and perfectly curved shoreline made it one of the most memorable places for travelers looking to end their year somewhere bright, calm, and deeply romantic.

Why It’s in Contention

Cap Juluca stands out for its unbeatable beachfront setting and unmistakable architectural presence. Its combination of low-key luxury, attentive service, and postcard-perfect scenery kept it at the forefront of the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, especially for guests drawn to relaxed elegance and natural beauty.

Best For

Romantic travelers, beach purists, and anyone who prioritizes a quiet, luxurious stretch of sand paired with polished, intuitive service.

Fun Fact

Maundays Bay’s crescent shape naturally amplifies the color of the water, giving it that almost unreal turquoise hue Cap Juluca is famous for.

‎

#2 – Jade Mountain (St. Lucia)

Sliding into the #2 spot, Jade Mountain remains one of the Caribbean’s most visually arresting resorts, perched high above St. Lucia’s southwestern coastline. Its open-air sanctuaries, infinity pools, and uninterrupted Piton views made it a signature year-end destination for travelers seeking something dramatic and unforgettable.

Why It’s in Contention

Jade Mountain’s ranking is driven by its architectural boldness and immersive sense of place. With its iconic three-walled design and private plunge pools, the resort stayed firmly among the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, resonating especially with guests who prioritize romance, privacy, and one-of-a-kind views.

Best For

Honeymooners, design lovers, and couples looking for an intensely private, scenic escape that feels both cinematic and deeply serene.

Fun Fact

Every suite — called a “sanctuary” — is individually designed, and many feature infinity pools that appear to blend seamlessly into the Caribbean Sea.

‎

#1 – Secret Bay (Dominica)

Taking the #1 position, Secret Bay stands as one of the Caribbean’s most intimate and soulful luxury retreats. Set along Dominica’s lush cliffs, the resort’s freestanding villas, private pools, and deep connection to nature made it a powerful year-end favorite for travelers craving privacy, immersion, and meaningful escape.

Why It’s in Contention

Secret Bay excels through its blend of sustainability, seclusion, and highly personalized service. Its award-winning design and low-density layout helped it rise to the top of the top resorts in the Caribbean Islands in 2025, especially for guests seeking a luxury experience rooted in nature rather than spectacle.

Best For

Privacy-focused travelers, eco-luxury enthusiasts, and guests who prefer an immersive, villa-style retreat that feels tailored, intentional, and quietly exclusive.

Fun Fact

The resort’s villas are built using sustainably harvested tropical hardwoods, designed to blend seamlessly into the island’s rainforest canopy.

‎

‎

Final Thoughts

As 2025 winds down, this wrap-up brings the year’s travel patterns into clear focus: guests sought out resorts that offered more than postcard views. The standouts were places with a strong identity — whether through architecture, deep privacy, wellness-driven intention, or a genuine sense of island connection. From the modern edges of Grenada to the wild cliffs of Dominica and the soft crescents of Anguilla, this year’s list shows how diverse the Caribbean experience can be when hospitality is thoughtful and rooted in place.

These ten properties didn’t simply deliver great stays; they shaped how travelers explored the region in 2025. Whether you’re planning next year’s return to the Caribbean or building a new destination wish list, this recap captures the resorts that defined the year — and continue to set the tone for what luxury in the islands can look like.