The Best Overall Cruise Lines in 2025

Every year, cruisers share thousands of firsthand reviews that offer an unfiltered look at how each cruise line actually performs. Cruiseline.com’s Member Choice Awards compile those insights into a clear, data-backed ranking built entirely from traveler experiences rather than promotional claims.

For 2025, the focus centers on which brands consistently delivered across service, ship quality, dining, entertainment, and overall value. These results reveal the best overall cruise lines in 2025, showcasing the companies that earned the strongest feedback across their entire fleets. Because the rankings reflect real traveler reviews, they offer one of the most reliable indicators of what guests truly enjoyed at sea.

If you’re choosing a cruise this year, this list provides a trustworthy starting point shaped by the people who sailed — not by the industry itself.

‎

#5 – Carnival Cruise Line

Carnival earned its place in the top five of the best overall cruise lines in 2025 thanks to strong guest satisfaction scores and a reputation for offering fun, high-energy vacations at approachable price points. Travelers consistently praised the line for its lively atmosphere, generous dining choices, and variety of entertainment options across its broad fleet.

Why It Ranked Well

Carnival performed well in categories such as value, onboard activities, and dining flexibility. Its ships are designed to appeal to a wide range of travelers, and its commitment to creating upbeat, social environments resonated with guests seeking an easygoing, activity-filled getaway.

What Travelers Consistently Mentioned

Reviewers commonly highlighted the friendly staff, diverse food options, and upbeat onboard vibe. Many guests appreciated the entertainment lineup, spacious pool decks, and itineraries suited for shorter, more casual vacations.

Best For

Families, first-time cruisers, social travelers, and guests looking for fun-focused, budget-friendly sailings.

‎

#4 – Holland America Line

Holland America Line maintained its strong position in the mainstream category of the best overall cruise lines in 2025, earning praise for its classic approach to cruising and consistently high service standards. Travelers appreciated the line’s quieter ships, curated enrichment programs, and itineraries emphasizing culture and destination depth.

Why It Ranked Well

The brand scored well in areas like service, dining quality, and onboard programming. Its mid-size ships appeal to guests who prefer a calmer environment, and the line’s destination-focused itineraries often draw travelers who enjoy learning as much as relaxing.

What Travelers Consistently Mentioned

Reviews often highlighted attentive service, well-prepared meals, and an atmosphere that feels relaxed and refined. Many guests also noted the smaller ship sizes make the experience feel more intimate and less crowded.

Best For

Mature travelers, culture-focused cruisers, enrichment seekers, and guests who enjoy quieter days at sea.

‎

#3 – Princess Cruises

Princess Cruises made an impressive return to the top rankings of the best overall cruise lines in 2025, earning strong review scores after being absent from the list in 2023 and 2024. Travelers consistently praised the brand for its comfortable ships, balanced onboard atmosphere, and itineraries that emphasize exploration and relaxation in equal measure.

Why It Ranked Well

Princess performed well across multiple review categories, particularly service, dining quality, and overall comfort. The line’s focus on thoughtfully designed ships and dependable guest experiences resonated with travelers seeking a vacation that feels polished without being overly busy.

What Travelers Consistently Mentioned

Guests frequently pointed out the friendly crew, appealing ports of call, and ships that offer a calm, classic cruise feel. Many reviews highlighted Princess as a reliable choice with well-paced itineraries and consistently pleasant onboard environments.

Best For

Couples, mature travelers, relaxation-focused guests, and anyone who appreciates a steady, well-rounded cruising experience.

‎

#2 – Celebrity Cruises

Celebrity Cruises held firmly to the second spot of the best overall cruise lines in 2025, supported by consistently high traveler feedback across ship design, dining, and overall service. Its modern aesthetic and elevated yet approachable atmosphere made it a favorite among guests looking for a refined mainstream experience.

Why It Ranked Well

Celebrity earned strong marks for its contemporary ships, thoughtful dining choices, and attentive service culture. Travelers also noted that Celebrity provides a more relaxed, upscale feel compared to other mainstream lines, without transitioning fully into the premium category.

What Travelers Consistently Mentioned

Reviewers often highlighted the quality of cuisine, the calm onboard atmosphere, well-appointed staterooms, and a level of service that feels polished and sincere. Many also appreciated the overall ship design, describing it as comfortable and visually appealing.

Best For

Couples, design-forward travelers, food-focused cruisers, and anyone looking for elevated comfort within a mainstream price range.

‎

#1 – Royal Caribbean

Royal Caribbean secured the top position once again, earning the highest overall rating across its fleet. Travelers consistently praised the brand for its mix of innovative ships, wide-ranging entertainment, and reliable service that feels polished without being overly formal.

Why It Ranked Well

Royal Caribbean performed strongly across all major review categories—particularly ship quality, onboard programming, dining consistency, and family-friendly amenities. Its large fleet also means more travelers reviewed the line, giving the ranking additional strength and credibility.

What Travelers Consistently Mentioned

Guests frequently noted standout service, well-designed cabins, strong entertainment options, and ships that balance energy with comfort. Many reviews highlighted staff friendliness and ease of navigating both large and mid-size vessels.

Best For

Families, multi-generational groups, active travelers, and guests who enjoy a mix of entertainment, dining variety, and large-ship features.